Property Management Companies in Suffolk County, NY

Among management companies in Suffolk County with at least 25 Google reviews, the highest rated are Luxury Fire Island Homes (5.0 stars, 113 reviews), Keyrenter Eastern Long Island Property Management (5.0 stars, 60 reviews) and EMLAK REALTY (5.0 stars, 57 reviews). Ratings are Google Maps data as of November 9, 2026.

PropertyManagementSearch tracks 90 management companies serving Suffolk County, New York, with an average Google rating of 4.4 stars. 6 of them have 100 or more Google reviews.

Paid placements come first and are always labeled Featured. Next come firms we matched to an active state license (Verified Firm). Everyone else is ordered by Google rating weighted by review volume, so a 4.9 with 300 reviews outranks a 5.0 with 4. The full method is at https://propertymanagementsearch.com/how-we-rank.

Request written proposals from at least three firms using the same scope of work, confirm each firm's state license, ask who your day-to-day manager would be and how many associations they handle, and call two current client boards before signing.