Magill Property Management

3.5(25 Google reviews)
HOAProperty management company

Profile updated November 4, 2026

#23of 48 management firms we track in Staten Island · how we rank
3.5Google rating · market avg 3.9
25Google reviews · more than 72% of Staten Island firms
HOAproperty types we list them for
Address806 E Jersey St, Elizabeth, NJ 07201
Office hours
monday8 AM–5 PM
tuesday8 AM–5 PM
wednesday8 AM–5 PM
thursday8 AM–5 PM
friday8 AM–5 PM
saturdayClosed
sundayClosed

Looking for a new management company?

Tell us about your building once and request proposals from the firms you pick. Free for boards.

Request Proposals

Location and nearby firms

How Magill Property Management compares in Staten Island

Magill Property ManagementM. Holmes Realty Corp.PadOwl LLCARC Property Management
Google rating3.5 stars4.8 stars4.9 stars4.7 stars
Google reviews25159107106
Property typesHOAHOAHOAHOA, Condo
WebsiteNone foundYesYesYes

Frequently asked questions

What does Magill Property Management manage?

Magill Property Management appears in our directory for HOA management.

How is Magill Property Management rated?

Magill Property Management holds a 3.5 star Google rating across 25 reviews, compared with a 3.9 star average among the 48 management firms we track in Staten Island. Google reviews often come from residents as well as board members.

Where is Magill Property Management located?

Magill Property Management is at 806 E Jersey St, Elizabeth, NJ 07201. Phone: (908) 558-0284.

Is this your firm?

Claim your PropertyManagementSearch listing to correct your details, add the property types you manage, and hear from boards in Staten Island looking for a new manager. Free.

Other management firms in Staten Island

M. Holmes Realty Corp.

M. Holmes Realty Corp.

4.8(159 Google reviews)
HOA350 St Marks Pl 310 Ste 310, Staten Island, NY 10301 · (718) 925-3327
PadOwl LLC

PadOwl LLC

4.9(107 Google reviews)
HOA1957 Richmond Ter, Staten Island, NY 10302 · (888) 572-3695
ARC Property Management

ARC Property Management

4.7(106 Google reviews)
HOACondo97 Newkirk St Ste 319, Jersey City, NJ 07306 · (551) 444-9010
Grinberg Management & Development

Grinberg Management & Development

4.5(106 Google reviews)
HOA31 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302 · (718) 414-6984

EWC Property Management

4.3(86 Google reviews)
HOACondo1000 South Ave Ste LL1, Staten Island, NY 10314 · (718) 980-3657
CRM Management Services, LLC & CRM REAL ESTATE

CRM Management Services, LLC & CRM REAL ESTATE

4.8(62 Google reviews)
HOACondo401 Bloomingdale Rd Ste 4, Staten Island, NY 10309 · (718) 684-9396
Magill Property Management: Staten Island, NY Property Management | License, Ratings & Contact | PropertyManagementSearch