At Home in Key West by AvantStay

At Home in Key West by AvantStay

4.5(239 Google reviews)
HOAProperty management company

Profile updated October 19, 2026

License not matched yet

Florida requires firms that manage community associations to hold a community association management firm license. We have not matched this listing to one. Ask the firm for its license number and confirm it on MyFloridaLicense.com.

Verify on MyFloridaLicense.com
#5of 46 management firms we track in Key West · how we rank
4.5Google rating · market avg 4.6
239Google reviews · more than 93% of Key West firms
HOAproperty types we list them for
414professionals we track at this firm

About At Home in Key West by AvantStay

AvantStay manages upscale vacation rental homes in Key West, specializing in luxury properties including private and communal pool homes designed for various group sizes and preferences.

Services

vacation rental managementproperty owner supportguest check-in and check-outpool maintenance coordinationproperty marketinghousekeeping coordinationcustomer servicereservation managementlocal area expertiseowner communication
Address905 Truman Ave, Key West, FL 33040

Looking for a new management company?

Tell us about your building once and request proposals from the firms you pick. Free for boards.

Request Proposals

Location and nearby firms

How At Home in Key West by AvantStay compares in Key West

At Home in Key West by AvantStayLast Key Realty LLCBrightwildCoconut Beach Resort
State licenseNot matchedNot matchedYes, CAB6754Yes, CAB1182
Licensed since--20262009
Google rating4.5 stars4.9 stars4.7 stars4.5 stars
Google reviews2392,574660244
Property typesHOAHOAHOA, CondoHOA, Condo
WebsiteYesYesYesYes

Team (414 professionals tracked)

Isabella Faife

Associate Director, Strategic Asset Management

Megan W

Associate Director of Policy, Regulatory Operations

Nick Picarelli

Procurement Manager

Kelly Matera

Area Manager

Laureen O'connor

Assistant Area Manager Tahoe

Christina Mcelroy

Senior Manager, Owner Success and Onboarding

Jayson Correa

Guest Experience Manager

Jocelyn Mungaray

Assistant Area Manager with AvantStay

Victoria Bayless

Assistant Area Manager

Jaron Caston

Project Manager

Jules Tran

Manager Project

Steve Brooke

Vice President Of Accounting

Frequently asked questions

Is At Home in Key West by AvantStay a licensed community association management firm?

We have not matched At Home in Key West by AvantStay to a Florida community association management firm license yet. Florida requires one for firms that manage associations, so ask the firm for its license number and confirm it on MyFloridaLicense.com before signing.

What does At Home in Key West by AvantStay manage?

At Home in Key West by AvantStay lists these services on its website: vacation rental management, property owner support, guest check-in and check-out, pool maintenance coordination, property marketing, housekeeping coordination, customer service, reservation management, local area expertise, owner communication.

How is At Home in Key West by AvantStay rated?

At Home in Key West by AvantStay holds a 4.5 star Google rating across 239 reviews, compared with a 4.6 star average among the 46 management firms we track in Key West. Google reviews often come from residents as well as board members.

Where is At Home in Key West by AvantStay located?

At Home in Key West by AvantStay is at 905 Truman Ave, Key West, FL 33040. Phone: (833) 442-8268.

Is this your firm?

Claim your PropertyManagementSearch listing to correct your details, add the property types you manage, and hear from boards in Key West looking for a new manager. Free.

Other management firms in Key West

Last Key Realty LLC

4.9(2,574 Google reviews)
HOA825 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040 · (305) 292-6266
Brightwild

Brightwild

4.7(660 Google reviews)
Verified Firm
HOACondo430 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040 · (305) 294-3265
Coconut Beach Resort

Coconut Beach Resort

4.5(244 Google reviews)
Verified Firm
HOACondo1500 Alberta St, Key West, FL 33040 · (305) 294-0057
1800 Atlantic/All Florida Keys Property Management

1800 Atlantic/All Florida Keys Property Management

4.5(193 Google reviews)
HOACondo1223 White St #102, Key West, FL 33040 · (800) 433-2819
Key West Vacation Properties & Realty

Key West Vacation Properties & Realty

4.9(154 Google reviews)
Verified Firm
HOACondo323 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040 · (305) 296-6667
Southernmost Sanctuary in Key West by Vacasa

Southernmost Sanctuary in Key West by Vacasa

4.7(160 Google reviews)
HOA1330 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040 · (855) 861-5757
At Home in Key West by AvantStay: Key West, FL Property Management | License, Ratings & Contact | PropertyManagementSearch